Archives

The Importance of Body Image

Negative body image has become so common that many people who work in this field refer to it as a “normative discontent”. Because obsession with appearances are so much a part of the fabric of our society we can fail to see how problematic our attitudes towards our bodies are because “everybody thinks this way don’t they”? Our society is obsessed with thinness. We are bombarded daily with unrealistic beliefs that thinness is healthy, easily achieved and attainable by all.

Thomas Cash did a survey of 33 thousand people in the States in 1972, 1985 and again in 1996. Women’s overall dislike of their physical appearance rose from 23% to 56% in those 24 years. For men, their dislike of their appearance rose from 15% to 43%. Despite many of these individuals being at a healthy weight Cash found that ½ of the women and ¼ of the men believed that they were overweight. Overall body image and self-esteem are more closely related to what people believe about their weight than to their actual weight.

Children as young as 6 are now found to be expressing body dissatisfaction and weight preoccupation and by the end of elementary school half or more of girls are dissatisfied with their weight and shape. This statistic is comparable to adolescent girls and adult women. A study in Ontario of 400 grade 7 and 8 girls showed that 60% were dieting to lose weight while other surveys conducted with North American teens show similar and even a higher prevalence of body dissatisfaction and dieting.

These statistics have profound implications in that how we feel about ourselves has a tremendous influence on our behaviors ranging from what we eat, the physical activity we do, drug and alcohol use, and even risk taking. For some body image dissatisfaction leads to severe eating problems. As the prevalence for body image dissatisfaction rises so does the prevalence of eating disorders and in particular the incidence of bulimia. Men are increasingly affected as a recent study from the University of Toronto found that 1 in 6 anorexics are men. The worse we see ourselves, the worse we treat ourselves.

People with poor body image are at higher risk for depression and low self-esteem. They are also more likely to have poor health due to severe dieting and use of steroids for example. Because they don’t like the way they look people with poor body image avoid social situations which can lead to social isolation. Can you see the vicious cycle? Isolation, depression, and low self-esteem are all significantly related to poor health.

If this and the previous blog on body image has made you realize that you or a loved one is struggling please refer to coming blogs that provide further information on what causes poor body image and what we can do to improve it. If you would like to speak to a therapist, we would be happy to help you.

Written by: Shawna Atkins, Ph.D., OPQ

Body Image

Grab a piece of paper and take note at how often you answer yes to the following questions.

  • I have struggled with my weight for years
  • I am very concerned about my weight
  • I am critical of my body
  • I tend to laugh off compliments about my body
  • I am very concerned about parts of my body that are either inadequate or too adequate
  • I am uncomfortable in social situations where I feel I am being watched
  • I hate to wear a bathing suit in public
  • I am uncomfortable eating in public
  • I don’t like my partner to see me naked
  • I don’t like to see me naked
  • I feel ashamed of my body
  • I seek refuge under the sheets during lovemaking
  • I compare myself mentally to visual images of “ideal” women or men
  • I often tell myself that I’ll take control again in the morning and attempt to diet
  • I want to lose a prescribed amount of weight before I go on vacation, a wedding, or go back home
  • When my partner tells me they love me just the way I am, I wonder what they could possibly mean.

What is Body Image?

Body Image is made up of 2 components:

  • How you perceive your body
  • How you feel about that perception

How we perceive our body is pretty consistent over time even though we all experience rough days & better days. In general, we tend to be more critical than loving of our bodies. We all know someone who we think looks great and then hear them complain about body parts that he or she dislikes.

Our emotions are an important part of body image. There are many people who are perceived as attractive by others but who feel negatively about themselves. Conversely, a person may be overweight and feel great in their body.

The combination of what you see and how you feel about it can range from positive to negative. Our degree of satisfaction and dissatisfaction can vary on a continuum from Body Ownership & Acceptance to Body Hate.

As you read the following list, circle the statements that apply to you.

Body Ownership

  • Body Image is not an issue for me
  • My body is beautiful to me
  • Society’s concept of a beautiful body does not influence how I feel about my body
  • I appreciate various aspects about my body, such as shape, function, flexibility
  • I know that significant others in my life appreciate my body and appearance

Body Acceptance

  • I feed my body well so that it is strong and healthy
  • My body image is based on social norms & my own self concept
  • My body and appearance are important to me but I spend only a small part of my day thinking about them
  • My self esteem is not based on how my body looks

Body Obsessed

  • I have days when I feel fat and unattractive
  • I spend a significant amount of time looking at my body in the mirror
  • I am preoccupied with my body and appearance
  • I regularly compare my body to others
  • I am influenced by and accept the societal norms for the ideal body
  • I would be more attractive if I were thinner or more muscular

Distorted Body Image

  • I spend a significant amount of time trying to change my body through exercising or dieting
  • My body image and appearance has interfered with my social activities such as dating or going out with friends
  • I have considered changing my body shape or have changed it through surgery
  • I wish I could change the way I look

Body Hate

  • Often my body feels as though it doesn’t belong to me but to someone else
  • When other people tell me I look okay I don’t believe them
  • I hate the way I look
  • I often isolate myself from others because I hate my body
  • I don’t see anything positive or even neutral about my body
  • I don’t feel comfortable in my body

Ownership      Acceptance    Obsessed        Distorted        Hate

The category in which you have circled the most statements will indicate where you fall on this continuum. Consider this along with how you answered the initial quiz. If you answered yes more than 4 times you are struggling with your body image. Obviously, the higher your “yes” score the bigger the problem and the further down this continuum you likely are. For those of you who scored 9 or higher or see yourself in the more problematic categories on the continuum it may be affecting you mood, your relationships and your activities. You could benefit a great deal by talking to a professional and working with them to make changes in how you feel about you.

Written by: Shawna Atkins, Ph.D., OPQ

How can EMDR help as part of therapy

EMDR and Trauma:

During the process of your therapy you may be asked if you would consider doing EMDR as a form of psychotherapy. It is important that you know what happens during this process and what we actually know about how this works. Most of the therapists at Westmount Psychological Services do practice EMDR and this requires added training, as it is not incorporated into the regular programs at university. It is a highly specialized form of psychotherapy that was originally designed for the treatment of Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. However as research into trauma has grown, we are now more aware of how not everyone suffering from traumatic experiences had to have big traumas (such as going to war) in order for these traumas to have a long and lasting effect.

It has been noted that people that have experienced very difficult events at times when they were overwhelmed and could not process them store these memories with all the attached impressions (thoughts, feelings, body sensations) as unprocessed memories in their brains. Then when something happens years later that one might think, feel or even physically react to in the same manner then that old trauma is again triggered and the person reacts to the present event the same way that they reacted to the original experience.

An example:

Martin is an only child and his parents have never had time for him. He is lonely and sad but when you look at his life it appears that he has a really good one. He goes to a private school, is well dressed, has great vacations and lives in a really nice house. But Martin does not feel cared about; no one seems to be interested in him or what he does and when he tries to approach anyone they just get angry with him and tell him to figure things out himself. Martin is too young to be able to process these events so he stores them as unprocessed memories and grows up believing that something is wrong with him; people do not want to be with him and he makes everyone angry. So now Martin is sad all the time; he is lonely but does nothing to make friends and/or have a social life. He hates himself because he sees everyone else having fun and he spends every weekend alone. Now more than ever he knows that there is something wrong and he truly believes that it is him. He is riddled with shame and anger.

So when Martin goes to his boss and asks to speak with him and the boss tells him that he has too much to do so could they speak tomorrow, Martin reacts with the same feelings and beliefs that he did when his parents rejected him years ago. He cannot hear that the boss has a problem and therefore cannot see him right away; he reacts that he is the problem and why should the boss want to talk to him anyway. He leaves feeling shame and painful emotions of more rejection and sadness.

How can EMDR help Martin: The goal of EMDR is to desensitize the emotions that still occur when old traumas are accessed and thus allow you to process them so that you can move forward and change the lens that you use to view your world. So with Martin we would use EMDR to help him access the pain of believing that he is not good enough – of being flawed – and help soothe that pain so he could reprocess what happened to him as a child and come to the realization that what was flawed was his parent’s parenting techniques – not him. This will also help Martin to begin to recognize many of the other times in his life that simple events built onto the original trauma and how – unless processed – it will continue to grow (e.g. the boss asking him to wait until tomorrow).

How big does the trauma have to be?

EMDR began by being used for big traumas such as Viet Nam veterans and more recent events such as the Okalahoma bombing. But the idea that someone needed to have had a big trauma to experience Post Traumatic Stress Disorder is no longer substantiated.  Many smaller events in one’s life can lead to some PTSD (such as Martin’s neglect, divorce, health problems, etc.) and can as demonstrated grow to be much bigger over time. We call these small T’s (T for trauma) rather than the big T’s of war or severe injury such as rape or assault. But nonetheless small T’s accumulate and can have the same effect as a big ‘T’ later in life. So we often hear people tell us that nothing really horrible ever happened but just a lot of small things that were hard to live with; however all these little events accumulate into bigger traumas and shape the lens that one uses to view their world.

How do you do it?

We begin by bringing up a painful memory and helping you to find the right negative belief that you have about yourself – like Martin’s belief “I am not good enough” and using the memory and the belief we will ask you to follow a light stream from left to right; we may also use tones that you will hear from earphones. After about approximately 25 cycles we will stop the light  bar and ask you what memories are coming up for you. Slowly as this process continues and you address the memories that are connected to that negative belief you will process them and free yourself of the hurt and pain related to those events. So Martin would process any memories of when he felt ‘not good enough’ and recognize that this was his reaction and not necessarily the other person’s reality.

Summary:

EMDR is not a form of hypnotism nor does it create memories. It is a process that we use to help you to access your own unprocessed memories and help to soothe you so that you are capable of processing them. This form of therapy is often faster than other forms but it does not happen overnight. If there is a lot of trauma it can take a long time to reprocess all the bad memories. But EMDR does work for many people and for Martin the hope would be that it will allow him to look back and realize how sad it was to have grown up in a family where his parents neglected him – but he will no longer feel that strong emotional pain because he will be able to give back the responsibility of his parent’s actions to his parents. We will have helped him to connect what perhaps he has known for a long time (my parents did not know how to parent) with his maladaptive feelings of being the one that is flawed. This connection will allow him to move forward into a new reality and one that tells him he is important and valuable. But now he still needs to learn how to change his own behaviors so that he can learn to make friends and have a healthy social life, which will end the shame and loneliness.

If you would like to try EMDR, give us a call.

Written by: Judith Norton, R.N., Ph.D.